Why is it, generally speaking, that Western medicine tends to throw pills at the symptom and not get to the underlying condition that may be causing the problem to begin with? Is it because we are lazy and want a quick fix? Is it decades of training doctors in a certain way? Is it an inability to change with the times? Is it fear of some kind?
Don’t get me wrong, I myself took an antidepressant because I needed it to get my chemical imbalance, well, balanced. I suffered for years from depression and/or clinical depression, and it had gotten to the point that even though I so did not want to take it, I knew I had to. I fought it for a long time, but when I was in Key West in the bright February sunshine, out of the frigid Chicago winter, and I was still feeling awful, I knew the time had come. At the time, I was seeing a therapist and he recommended a psychiatrist to me. I reluctantly went. The deal was I would continue with my therapist and I would see the psychiatrist once a month. I made sure my doctor knew from the very beginning that I had no intention of staying on the medication indefinitely. I asked how long I would have to take it. My doctor told me, and keep in mind this was in 1997, usually people took it for about a year, maybe a little longer. I said, okay, but I’m not taking it any longer than that.
At the time I was trying to get pregnant and, again keep in mind it was 1997, at the time the only antidepressant that was approved for and that had been tested on pregnant women was prozac. So that’s what I was given. Pretty sure I’ve mentioned this before, but it nearly killed me. Every bad side-effect it was possible to get, I got. I know now I should never have been given it at all, since I am in the bi-polar spectrum, and prozac is a huge no-no. Not sure if this wasn’t known back then or that my doctor just dropped the ball, in a way. It doesn’t really matter. What matters is I was closely monitored and switched to wellbutrin as soon as it became clear that I was on the wrong medication.
What I find astounding is the number of people, mostly women, who have been on antidepressants for years. YEARS! And they have no intention of ever getting off of them. I understand that there are legitimate reasons for being on a drug long-term, maybe even forever; but, mostly, I don’t believe this to be the case. (Bi-polar disorder is a different story and those with it should take medication, though many don’t/won’t.) I could not wait to stop taking it, even after finding the correct one for me. It was a hateful drug, and though it accomplished what I needed, the re-balancing my chemicals, I was not sorry when I no longer had to take it.
And these days the hottest new ‘disorders’ to be diagnosed with are ADD and ADHD. In the November issue of Oprah, an article written by Anna Maltby addresses this phenomenon, and it is alarming. “A groundbreaking report released earlier this year by the prescription management company Express Scripts stated that the number of adults in the United States taking ADHD medications (which include Ritalin and Concerta, in addition to Adderall) rose 53 percent from 2008 to 2012. It also found that women are using ADHD medication at notably higher rates than girls, with those in the 26 to 34 age range posting a staggering 85 percent jump in the use of such drugs in just five years.” According to ADHD researcher Keith Connors, PhD, professor emeritus at Duke University and the creator of a highly regarded rating scale commonly used to help diagnose the disorder, “It’s clear that one reason for the recent rise is over diagnosis.” He goes on to say that, “There is a swarm of primary care doctors and psychiatrists who really don’t know that much about ADHD but are willing to give out a prescription.”
According to webmd.com:
“Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is one of the most well-recognized childhood developmental problems. This condition is characterized by inattention, hyperactivity and impulsiveness. It is now known that these symptoms continue into adulthood for about 60% of children with ADHD. That translates into 4% of the U.S. adult population, or 8 million adults. However, few adults are identified or treated for adult ADHD.
ADHD in Adults
Adults with ADHD may have difficulty following directions, remembering information, concentrating, organizing tasks, or completing work within time limits. If these difficulties are not managed appropriately, they can cause associated behavioral, emotional, social, vocational, and academic problems.
Common Behaviors and Problems of Adult ADHD
The following behaviors and problems may stem directly from ADHD or may be the result of related adjustment difficulties:
Chronic lateness and forgetfulness
Difficulty concentrating when reading
Difficulty controlling anger
Low frustration tolerance
Poor organization skills
Substance abuse or addiction”
(After reading the list above, I doubt there is anyone on the planet that doesn’t suffer from several, if not most, of them. Doesn’t mean you need to be medicated, though.)
Okay, the truth is I probably had/have ADHD, but even if this is the case, I have learned how to manage in spite of it. I have a friend who kind of makes fun of me because I have, in her words, a very rigid routine. What I now understand is, in order for me to function at the level I need to, to be able to be self-employed, it is imperative that I have a fixed routine. I don’t consider it to be rigid, but I do my best to stick with it on a daily basis, otherwise nothing gets done. Or at least not a lot gets accomplished. Would a drug like Adderall help me? Maybe, but I prefer to have my ‘rigid’ routine. And let me say again, I do believe there are people who legitimately need to be on one of these drugs. At the same time, I believe that many are misdiagnosed/overdiagnosed by physicians who simply do not know enough about it.
I feel like there are so many other available choices, such as diet, exercise, therapy, that may help, if not alleviate the problem all together. Ultimately, though, we each need to do what we decide is best.